First Presbyterian / First Christian Church
200 Jefferson Avenue
Owner/agent: James Buckner, Wilkins & Co. 434-688-1589
Square Feet: 8,728 Lot: 17,860
Asking: $179,000 Reduced to $99,000 Annual property tax: $1,242
Beautiful Old Church built c. 1879 with a lot of that Old World Charm. Building features an area that was used as an apartment that moves into a large basic fellowship hall. There features a big kitchen area as well. Large sanctuary with pews and a 1899 Moeller pipe organ, Opus 266, Enameled Stained Glass Windows. Heat, air, and electrical update 2007.
260 Jefferson Avenue
Owner/agent: Held for resale, please inquire
Square Feet: 2,816 Lot: 1,980
Storefront with possible apartment above.
This building was Hagan Drugs and then Central Pharmacy. In the 1930s and 1940s, it was a Kroger grocery. Later, it became part of the Holsum Bakery complex which occupied several more buildings to the right, now demolished.
This building has a brand new internal structure and roof. Rock solid.
400 Jefferson Street
Owner/agent: Held for resale, please inquire
Square Feet: 2,424 Lot: 1,212 (Adjoining lot: 1,482)
Storefront and apartment. The adjoining lot to the left left with false facade is also available.
For many years, this building was home to the West Piano Company.
The adjoining lot (variously numbered 400½ and 402) was, for many years Pattisalls Confectionery.
406 Jefferson Street
Owner/agent: Held for resale, please inquire
Square Feet: 2,848 Lot: 1,617 (Adjoining lot: 1,482)
Two storefronts, two apartments or one over one. The adjoining lot at right with false facade is also available.
Variously numbered 402, 404, and 406 over the years, this building was most often home to a neighborhood grocer. Callahan Cleaners was located here in the 1980s.
The adjoining lot (variously numbered 400½ and 402) was, for many years Pattisalls Confectionery.
413-419 Jefferson Street
Owner/agent: Owner Mary Massie Barnes, 434-799-1017 or email
Square Feet: 2,744 Lot: 3,450
Three storefronts — Asking $40,000 for all three.
In the early 1950s, 419 Jefferson Street was Fuzzy’s Place. In the late 1950s, it was the Five Forks Soda Shop. They offered plate lunches, sandwiches, and fountain service.
In 1962, 419 was the Wagon Wheel Restaurant. At lunch, they offered a plate with meat and two vegetables plus a drink for 75 cents. By July 1963, the restaurant was completely air conditioned and offered a money-saving dinner every night from 5:30 until 7:00.